Skip to content

How to Tell Eczema and Psoriasis Apart: A Guide for Rochester, NY Residents

Dermatology photo from Adobe Stock

What Are Eczema and Psoriasis?

Eczema and psoriasis are two of the most common chronic skin conditions affecting both children and adults throughout Rochester, NY. Both cause itchy, irritated skin but have distinct differences that impact treatment, daily management, and quality of life. Understanding how these conditions differ helps residents make informed choices in personal care—especially given the pronounced seasonal shifts and indoor heating practices common in the area.

How Do Eczema and Psoriasis Look Different?

While both conditions cause red, itchy patches, their appearance on the skin is usually quite distinct.

    • Eczema tends to look like dry, rough, scaly patches that may ooze or crust, especially after scratching. In Rochester’s cold winters, eczema often intensifies on exposed areas like hands and cheeks. Eczema is especially common in skin folds, such as elbows and behind knees.
    • Psoriasis, on the other hand, most often produces thicker, raised plaques with a silvery-white scale. These plaques can occur anywhere but are frequent on the scalp, elbows, knees, or lower back. Unlike eczema, psoriasis plaques tend to be more sharply defined and less likely to weep.

Children and adults in Rochester may notice eczema tends to start earlier in life, while psoriasis typically appears in teenage or adult years.

Is the Itching the Same for Both?

The sensation of itch differs between these skin diseases.

    • Eczema often produces intense itching, which can be hard for adults and children to resist. Scratching can worsen the rash, leading to thickened skin or infections—especially during dry months when indoor air is heated.
    • Psoriasis typically causes mild to moderate itch or even a stinging, burning sensation. While it can still disrupt sleep or concentration, the urge to scratch is usually less severe than with eczema.

Local residents sometimes confuse dry winter skin with eczema, so persistent or intensely itchy rashes should be carefully examined, especially for children prone to scratching.

What Causes Eczema and Psoriasis?

Though both are chronic and often run in families, their underlying causes differ.

    • Eczema (atopic dermatitis) is most often linked to a combination of genetics, immune system sensitivity, and a weakened barrier in the skin that lets irritants penetrate. Triggers include soaps, fragrances, wool fabrics, cold air, or stress—triggers that are common in Rochester households during long winters.
    • Psoriasis is an autoimmune condition where skin cells multiply too quickly, leading to thick plaques. It can be triggered by infections, skin injuries, some medications, or significant life stress. Winter flare-ups can be more dramatic as dry indoor conditions affect the skin, but the root process is not due to an external irritant.

Many local families note that eczema seems to "run in the family," and the same can be true for psoriasis. However, unlike eczema, psoriasis is not caused or worsened by allergies.

Are There Sensitive Seasons in Rochester?

The climate and home heating patterns in Rochester can have a noticeable effect on both eczema and psoriasis.

    • Winter: Both conditions commonly worsen when indoor heating dries the air. Residents may see an uptick in symptoms during colder months when moisture in the skin is lost faster and people spend more time indoors with potential allergens like dust mites or pet dander.
    • Summer: High humidity may relieve symptoms for some with eczema, but sweat and heat can trigger flares—especially with lingering pool chlorine or outdoor pollen.

Many local households find that investing in a home humidifier and using thicker fragrance-free moisturizers helps keep winter symptoms at bay, though these are not cures.

How Are These Conditions Diagnosed?

Diagnosis involves more than just looking at the rash—especially in a city with long winters where many residents have dry or irritated skin at some point.

Doctors usually diagnose eczema and psoriasis based on the appearance and behavior of the rash, family history, and the age at which symptoms started. In rare cases, a small skin biopsy may be used to confirm psoriasis if there is uncertainty.

Locally, households are sometimes surprised to learn that symptoms assumed to be “just dry skin from the winter” can point to these chronic conditions.

What Misconceptions Do Rochester Residents Have?

Despite the prevalence of both conditions, misconceptions are common.

Dermatology photo from Adobe Stock

    • Many believe both are caused purely by allergies, but psoriasis is not allergy-related.
    • Eczema is sometimes confused with “contact dermatitis,” a skin reaction to touching an irritant, but most people with eczema have a longstanding history of sensitive skin.
    • It’s a myth that either condition is contagious. Both are immune-driven and cannot be "caught" from another person.
    • Self-diagnosis can be difficult. In Rochester, dry indoor air can cause symptoms similar to either condition, so ongoing, severe, or unusual rashes should be properly distinguished.

How Do Eczema and Psoriasis Affect Daily Life?

Both can affect confidence, sleep, and daily routines. Children dealing with itching may find it hard to concentrate in school. Adults sometimes modify clothing choices or daily habits, particularly during peak flare seasons. Locally, residents should consider:

    • Protective clothing during winter to reduce skin exposure and irritation
    • Gentle, unscented detergents and soaps
    • Frequent moisturizing, especially after bathing
    • Awareness that stress, cold weather, and skin injuries can provoke symptoms

Community understanding and practical management strategies go a long way in reducing discomfort and social stigma.

Are Treatments Different for Eczema and Psoriasis?

Because their root causes differ, treatments aren’t always interchangeable.

    • Eczema is typically managed by restoring the skin barrier with moisturizers, avoiding known irritants, and sometimes with topical steroids or non-steroid anti-inflammatory creams.
    • Psoriasis may also use topical treatments but often requires medicines that affect the immune system or targeted therapies to slow skin cell growth.

Area households managing either condition should work with medical professionals for persistent, severe, or worsening symptoms—especially if bleeding, cracking, or infection develops.

About the Author

Dr. Lesley Loss

A board-certified dermatologist and Rochester, NY, native, Dr. Lesley Loss is the president and owner of Dermatology Associates of Rochester. She is a skilled skincare specialist who performs both medical and cosmetic dermatology procedures. Her expertise includes anti-aging treatments such as injectable fillers and laser skin rejuvenation.

After graduating summa cum laude from Colby College in Maine, Dr. Loss returned to New York where she graduated with Latin honors from the University of Buffalo’s Jacobs School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences. She finished a year of internal medicine training at the University of Rochester Medical Center before completing her dermatology residency at the University of Buffalo, where she served as chief resident.